By Daniel Todaro, CEO at Gekko Group
With increasing overheads, a growing tax burden and changing employment laws, retailers are understandably cutting headcount in favour of AI and technology-enabled services. At a time when many retailers, particularly those with a physical presence, are under pressure this is a rational decision but there are some significant drawbacks that are being overlooked – and it could come back to haunt them.
Physical retail still plays a vital role in the customer journey
Outside of the Black Friday rush, three quarters of purchases are still made in store, despite growing web traffic. The increase of webrooming – where consumers browse online before making a purchase in-store – and showrooming, where the opposite is true, highlights the need for consistent, high-quality experiences across channels.
Consumers often prefer to see a product in person before they commit to a purchase – even if that purchase is ultimately made online. This is particularly true of big-ticket items such as technology, white goods and furniture where shoppers want to know exactly what they are getting before they part with their money – especially so in today’s market where many single people and families are feeling squeezed financially.
It is easy to assume that simply having trial or sample products available meets these needs, but there is an additional layer that is often being forgotten: advice. Consumers have reviews and product information at their fingertips, but sometimes they want to discuss their prospective purchases with someone in the know and that is where staffing matters.
When shoppers go into a store and cannot find anyone to assist them, it detracts from the experience and often causes them to either abandon their purchase or feel undervalued, which can often damage their perception of the retailer or brand.
Information is no substitute for experience and expertise
Experienced and well-trained staffing becomes even more important when it comes to complex products. Let’s say you are in the market for a new wearable, a fitness tracker for example: there are an overwhelming volume of options available – brand, model, specification, price point. The discovery process is exhausting and it’s difficult to tell the difference between products, especially with limited technical knowledge and expertise.
Your friends have told you what they have and you might know that you want a ring over a watch or band, but beyond that it can be a slog. Which model works for you and your lifestyle: top of the range or will a less expensive version meet your needs? You have done your research but the information available is confusing and conflicted, so you decide to go into a store to try out some options and speak to an expert who can help you make the decision, but it takes you a long time to find a member of staff, and when you do, they often can’t provide the kind of expert advice and genuine user experience that you’re after..
Here the issue is not only headcount, but expertise. When it comes to big-ticket items, retailers and brands must be equipped to convert confusion into action. Training budgets are being cut to reduce overheads, with in-person practical training being replaced by online learning. Digital updates provide a solid foundation, but surface-level modules do not inspire teams’ confidence or build their ability to sell more complex products and services. As tech products – wearables, laptops, mobile phones, white goods and even small domestic appliances – become increasingly complex and more confusing for the average shopper, the need for in-depth knowledge is becoming a necessity rather than a nice to have to avoid buyers’ remorse.
Brands with more complicated products should consider placing brand ambassadors in store or providing additional training to stockists’ staff to ensure that someone is on hand to answer challenging questions, reassure shoppers and help them find the model that will strike the best balance between their needs and their budget. This high-quality experience engenders trust and brand equity, which is vital for long-term commercial success as the cost of ambassadors outweighs the potential failure and delisting of a brand and its products. If standards slip, and sales are low, it can have a sizeable impact on the bottom line.
Overreliance on AI can be detrimental
In-store staffing and expertise is essential, but the experience needs to be consistent across touchpoints. With consumers increasingly browsing or researching products online, product labelling, descriptions, images and tags must be accurate to be discoverable, accessible and comparable. Digital shelf management is one area where automated services and AI can be incredibly valuable – but when it comes to the wider customer experience, the overreliance on technology is letting many brands and retailers down.
Customer service is a vital part of the customer journey. While much of this has moved online, chatbots are rapidly becoming a replacement for human interactions as retailers take advantage of technology to reduce overheads. However, 83% of consumers still prefer to speak to a real person, and frustrating experiences with automated services are impacting the customer experience – and that’s costing businesses. Everyone knows when they are talking to a chatbot. If you want to make your customer feel valued, this isn’t going to achieve it.
A study from CEBR and Trustpilot published in October last year revealed that poor experiences with AI may have cost UK retail firms as much as £8.6bn in the previous 12 months – and with the industry already in a bind, this is a loss few retailers can afford. This shows the importance of having empathetic, expert staff available: even if a chatbot is the first point of contact, there is value in making the path to human interaction straightforward and allowing consumers to engage in a way that suits them.
In-store or online, human experience is the new premium
As AI interactions often disappoint and access to in-store support becomes limited, the human touch has become a rarity. Most consumers are prepared to pay more for better customer service, and as more retailers reduce their headcounts, being able to engage with real people – online and face-to-face – will be perceived as a premium experience.
This is particularly important for those selling those complex, big-ticket items. Customer experience should match the price point, and failing to deliver what shoppers want and need only fosters a feeling of dissatisfaction.















